Posted on 22 December 2025
Free Employee Evaluation Form Template Download Excel, Google Sheets, Word and PDF
- Available to download for free in Excel, Google Sheets, Word and PDF
- Rates 18 criteria on a 1 to 5 scale and turns them into a weighted score
- Flags ratings with no evidence and self vs manager gaps of 2 or more points
- Compares evaluators so one generous manager can’t skew the whole team
An employee evaluation form is a structured document managers use to rate an employee’s job performance against set criteria over a review period, record the evidence behind each rating, agree goals for the next period and capture signatures. It keeps reviews consistent across managers and creates a dated record for pay, promotion and probation decisions.
Last updated: November 17, 2026
What it is
An employee evaluation template that rates 18 criteria on a 1 to 5 scale, turns them into a weighted score and prints a one-page form for each person.
When you need it
Annual reviews, mid-year check-ins and 90-day probation reviews, whenever more than one manager is rating people.
What's inside
Settings, employees, ratings, goals, a team summary, an evaluator calibration view, a printable evaluation form and a comment bank.
Formats
Excel, Google Sheets, Word and PDF. The Word and PDF versions are a two-page form to fill in by hand.
Want to see it filled in first?
Make your own copy of the filled sample in Google Sheets.
What Is an Employee Evaluation Form?
Review week. Eight people to rate. One manager's memory of the last twelve months.
Guess which months get remembered? The last two.
An employee evaluation form is a structured document managers use to rate an employee's job performance against set criteria over a review period, record the evidence behind each rating, agree goals for the next period and capture signatures. It keeps reviews consistent across managers and creates a dated record for pay, promotion and probation decisions.
You'll hear it called plenty of names. A staff evaluation form. An employee assessment form. A performance evaluation form. An employee evaluation sheet. An appraisal form. Same job every time: the same questions for every person in the same role.
notes, numbers, attendance
18 criteria, 1 to 5
weighted by role
gaps discussed first
goals and signatures
Whatever you call it, an employee evaluation template should use one scale for everyone. So what is it not? It isn't a disciplinary letter, and it isn't a performance improvement plan. It also isn't a legal form. No law in the countries below prescribes one layout, so the form is your record, not a filing.

Employee Evaluation Form vs Performance Review vs Self-Evaluation vs PIP
These four get swapped all the time. Each one answers a different question.
| Document | The question it answers | Who fills it in | When |
|---|---|---|---|
| Employee evaluation form | How did this person perform against our criteria? | Manager, with the employee's self rating | Annual, mid-year or end of probation |
| Performance review | What did we agree in the conversation? | Manager and employee together | The meeting that uses the form |
| Self-evaluation | How does the employee rate their own work? | Employee | A week before the meeting |
| Performance improvement plan | What must change, by when? | Manager | After a low rating |
The weekly report collects the evidence, the evaluation form judges it, and the improvement plan acts on it.
Every evaluation form for employees needs a next step. Rated someone a 1 or 2 in a whole category? Move to a performance improvement plan with dates and support. Want evidence all year instead of at review time? Pair the form with an employee weekly report.
Which Version of the Evaluation Form Fits Your Review?
Start with who's being reviewed, and why. This staff evaluation form covers each case below.
| If your situation is... | Use this | Where to find it |
|---|---|---|
| Annual review for a whole team | Annual review type, weighted score, team summary | Excel or Google Sheets |
| A new hire reaching the end of probation | Probation (90-Day) review type with an outcome field | Employees sheet |
| You want the employee's view first | Self rating column beside the manager rating | Ratings sheet |
| Several managers are rating staff | Calibration view by evaluator | Calibration sheet |
| You fill forms by hand in the meeting | Two-page printable form | Word and PDF |
| You need an employee evaluation form sample | Filled form for 8 fictional employees | Google Sheets copy |
| The role itself is unclear | Write the role first with a job description template | Separate download |

What Does the Employee Evaluation Form Contain?
The Word form, the PDF and the printable employee evaluation sheet in Excel all carry these sections.
| Section | What goes in it | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Employee details | Name, ID, job title, department, evaluator, review type, period and date | Ties the ratings to one person, one role and one period |
| 18 criteria | Six categories with three criteria each | Everyone in the role is judged on the same things |
| Self and manager ratings | 1 to 5 for each criterion | Shows where the two views split |
| Comments and evidence | A fact, a number or an example | Makes a rating explainable a year later |
| Category averages and weights | Average per category, weight per role profile | A driver isn't rated like an accountant |
| Overall band and override | Weighted score, band, and a reason if the band is changed | Stops quiet changes to the final rating |
| Attendance | Unplanned absences, late arrivals, suggested rating | Puts numbers behind the punctuality score |
| Goals | Last period's goals with results, next period's goals with measures and dates | Links this review to the next one |
| Comments and signatures | Evaluator comments, employee comments, two signatures | Records that the review happened |
The Field That Matters Most: Comments and Evidence
A rating without a comment is an opinion. "2 on punctuality" invites an argument. "9 late arrivals against a limit of 5, discussed in June and September" ends it. That's why the workbook flags every 1, 2 or 5 that has no comment.
What the Enerpize Employee Evaluation Form Template Includes
We built the workbook around one question: what goes wrong in real reviews? Ratings with no evidence. Managers who score generously. Employees surprised in the meeting. Probation reviews that end with no decision. Each sheet catches one of these with formulas only. No macros, so it opens in Excel and Google Sheets without a warning.
A Ruler With Marks on It: The Anchored 1 to 5 Scale
A "3" means nothing until you write down what a 3 looks like. Settings holds a label and a meaning for every rating, plus "what a 1 looks like" and "what a 5 looks like" for all 18 criteria. Category weights change by role profile: Standard, Customer-facing and Field & Warehouse.

No Receipt, No Return: Evidence and Self Gaps Get Flagged
Every rating row has a Check column. A 1, 2 or 5 with no comment shows Add evidence. A self rating 2 or more points away from the manager's shows Talk: gap, so that criterion goes first in the meeting.

A Traffic Light for Every Employee: The Team Summary
One row per person: criteria rated out of 18, weighted score, final band, suggested and rated attendance, evidence gaps, goals met and a Status. Status shows the first thing to fix, from Incomplete to Ready.

Same Exam, Same Marker: Evaluator Calibration
The Calibration sheet compares each evaluator's average score with the company average. A gap of 0.5 or more shows Lenient? or Harsh?, so HR can review those ratings before anyone sees a final band.

The 1 to 5 Rating Scale, Color-Coded
What is the 5 point scale for employee evaluation? Here's the one in the template. Change the labels in Settings if your company uses different words.
| Rating | Label | What it looks like | Comment required | Score band |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Unsatisfactory | Falls well short of the standard. Needs a plan to improve. | Yes | Below 1.5 |
| 2 | Needs Improvement | Meets part of the standard. Clear gaps to close. | Yes | 1.5 to 2.49 |
| 3 | Meets Expectations | Fully meets the standard for the role. | No | 2.5 to 3.49 |
| 4 | Exceeds Expectations | Goes beyond the standard on a regular basis. | No | 3.5 to 4.49 |
| 5 | Excellent | Sets the standard others are measured against. | Yes | 4.5 and up |
Why do 5s need a comment too? Because generous ratings without evidence are as hard to defend as harsh ones, and they make the next pay conversation awkward.
| Category | Standard | Customer-facing | Field & Warehouse |
|---|---|---|---|
| Job Knowledge & Skills | 20% | 15% | 15% |
| Work Quality | 20% | 15% | 20% |
| Productivity & Efficiency | 20% | 15% | 20% |
| Communication & Teamwork | 15% | 25% | 10% |
| Initiative & Problem Solving | 15% | 15% | 10% |
| Attendance & Punctuality | 10% | 15% | 25% |
Example: A Filled Employee Evaluation Form Sample
The sample covers Cedar Street Supplies, a fictional business with 8 employees, two evaluators and a review period of 1 November 2025 to 31 October 2026. Make your own copy of the filled sample in Google Sheets and change the employee ID on the Evaluation Form sheet to see each person.

How to Read Maria Santos's Evaluation
Maria works in customer support, so her profile is Customer-facing. Four categories average 3.00, Communication & Teamwork reaches 3.67, and Attendance & Punctuality sits at 2.67.
Her weighted score is 3.12, which lands in Meets Expectations.
Now the interesting part. On "Arrives on time" she rated herself 5. Her manager gave 2, with a comment: 9 late arrivals against a limit of 5. That 3-point gap is flagged, so it's the first thing to talk about, not the last.
Her last goal, 90% of first replies within 4 hours, came in at 81%. Partly Met. Her two new goals both have a measure and a due date.
What the Team View Shows
Only 2 of 8 employees are Ready. Daniel has a 5 with no evidence. James is rated 4 on attendance, while his 6 absences and 12 late arrivals suggest a 2. Neha has 15 of 18 criteria rated. Sipho's probation review has no outcome yet.
And the evaluators? Samuel Osei averages 4.33 against a company average of 3.82. That's 0.51 above, so he's flagged as possibly lenient before any band is final.
Employee Evaluation Template Formulas
Every number in the workbook comes from one of these, with a worked example from the sample.
Category Average
Category average = sum of manager ratings in the category / number of criteria rated
Maria, Communication & Teamwork: (4 + 4 + 3) / 3 = 3.67.
Weighted Score
Weighted score = sum of (category average x category weight) / sum of weights of rated categories
Maria: (3 x 15 + 3 x 15 + 3 x 15 + 3.67 x 25 + 3 x 15 + 2.67 x 15) / 100 = 3.12. A category with no ratings drops out of both halves, so a half-finished form isn't dragged down by zeros.
Band
Band = the nearest whole rating: 1.5, 2.5, 3.5 and 4.5 are the dividing lines
3.12 sits between 2.5 and 3.49, so it's Meets Expectations.
Self Gap
Gap = manager rating minus self rating; flagged when the gap is 2 or more either way
Maria, "Arrives on time": 2 minus 5 = minus 3. Flagged.
Suggested Attendance Rating
Suggested rating = the lower of the absence rating and the lateness rating
Default limits for a rating of 5, 4, 3 and 2: up to 1, 3, 5 and 8 unplanned absences, and up to 2, 5, 10 and 15 late arrivals. James had 6 absences and 12 late arrivals, so both point to 2.
Evaluator Difference
Difference = evaluator's average score minus company average score
Samuel: 4.33 minus 3.82 = 0.51. At 0.5 or more, the flag is Lenient?
How to Use the Employee Evaluation Form Template?
1- Set the Scale and Weights
Open Settings. Enter your company and review period, check the labels, and adjust the weights for each role profile.
Why: a scale nobody agreed on produces ratings nobody trusts.
⚡ Tip: Keep weights adding to 100. The Total row shows it.
2- List Your Employees
One row per person: ID, job, evaluator, review type, weight profile, review date, unplanned absences and late arrivals.
Why: the attendance numbers drive the suggested attendance rating.
⚡ Tip: Take absences and late arrivals from your attendance records, not from memory.
3- Collect Self Ratings
Send each employee the Word form a week before the meeting and copy their self ratings into the Ratings sheet.
Why: the gap between two views is where the useful conversation is.
⚡ Tip: Ask for one example per category, not just numbers.
4- Rate All 18 Criteria
Enter the manager rating for every criterion, with evidence for any 1, 2 or 5.
Why: an unrated criterion leaves the score incomplete.
⚡ Tip: Use the Comment Bank as a starting point, then replace every bracket with a real fact.
5- Review Goals
Mark last period's goals as Met, Partly Met, Not Met or Dropped, with the actual result.
Why: goals without results turn the next review into guesswork.
⚡ Tip: Write the result as a number where you can: "81%", not "nearly there".
6- Fix Every Status
Open the Team Summary and work down the Status column until each person shows Ready.
Why: a flag fixed before the meeting is a surprise avoided in it.
⚡ Tip: Check Calibration last. A Lenient? or Harsh? flag is a prompt to review, not proof of bias.
7- Hold the Meeting
Print the Evaluation Form for the employee, start with any flagged gaps, then agree next period's goals.
Why: the form guides the conversation; it shouldn't replace it.
⚡ Tip: Let the employee talk first on each flagged criterion.
8- Sign and File
Both sign. The employee adds comments. File the signed form with the employee's records.
Why: a dated, signed record shows the review happened and what was agreed.
⚡ Tip: The signature confirms receipt and discussion, not agreement with every rating.
Common Employee Evaluation Mistakes
✕ Rating the last two months
Why it matters: Recent events crowd out the rest of the year, good and bad.
Fix: Keep notes or weekly reports through the year and rate from those.
✕ Extreme ratings with no evidence
Why it matters: A 1 or a 5 without a fact is hard to explain and easy to dispute.
Fix: Write one example for every 1, 2 or 5. The workbook flags any you miss.
✕ One strength colors every score
Why it matters: A great salesperson gets 5s on punctuality too. That's the halo effect.
Fix: Rate criterion by criterion, using the written anchors.
✕ Surprises in the meeting
Why it matters: A first mention of a problem at review time feels like an ambush.
Fix: Raise issues when they happen. Use the self gap flags to prepare.
✕ Different standards per manager
Why it matters: Two people doing the same job get different bands for the same work.
Fix: Compare evaluators on the Calibration sheet before bands are final.
✕ Goals with no measure
Why it matters: "Improve communication" can't be met or missed.
Fix: Add a target and a due date. The Goals sheet flags any next goal without both.
Importance of the Employee Evaluation Form
Here's the uncomfortable number. Gallup reports that only 14% of employees strongly agree the performance reviews they receive inspire them to improve, and only 29% strongly agree their reviews are fair.
So is the answer to stop evaluating? No. It's to make the evaluation fair enough to be believed.
It Makes Reviews Comparable
The same 18 criteria, scale and weights for everyone in a role. Otherwise two managers write two different reviews, and nobody can compare them.
It Puts Evidence Behind Pay and Promotion
Ratings with comments explain why one person moved up a band and another didn't.
It Turns Feedback Into Goals
A low category score becomes next period's goal, with a measure and a date. Next year's review then starts from a result instead of a memory.
It Keeps a Record
A dated, signed form shows what was discussed and when. In several countries below, that record has to be kept or handed over on request.
Spreadsheet vs HR Software for Employee Evaluations
| Employee evaluation template | HR software | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Free | Subscription |
| Set up | Minutes: fill in Settings | Longer: employees, structure, policies |
| Attendance numbers | Typed in from your records | Recorded as people sign in |
| Employee records | One workbook per review cycle | One profile per person, kept over time |
| Best for | Small teams and first review cycles | Teams growing past what a spreadsheet can hold |
How Enerpize Handles the Records Behind Every Evaluation
Where does the evidence for an evaluation come from? Attendance. Job titles. Departments. Probation dates. Enerpize keeps all of them in one place, so the numbers you type into an evaluation already exist.
Employee Records
Enerpize employee management keeps each person's profile with role, designation, department and branch. Its records cover performance, attendance and payroll, and it stores contracts, job history and performance reviews in one place.

Organizational Structure
Departments, designations, employee levels and employment types are set once and used everywhere. The org chart shows who reports to whom, which is also who evaluates whom.



Employee Levels and Employment Types
Group people by level, such as Director, Senior and Junior, and by employment type. Enerpize contracts define employment types, levels and probation periods, with reminders as contracts change.


Attendance and Leave
Enerpize attendance and leave management calculates delays and early dismissals from each sign-in, and reports cover detailed attendance, leave balances and department attendance. That's the absence and lateness count your evaluation needs, without anyone counting by hand.
Employee Self Service
With the Enerpize ESS app, employees see their own monthly sheet: working days, working hours, absences and total delay. Nobody hears an attendance number for the first time in their review.
Performance Tracking
Enerpize's workflow builder lets you set performance metrics and KPIs and track progress against them. Read more in our HR management guides.
Employee Evaluation Form for the United States
No federal law makes US employers run performance reviews. But once you do, the records count.
The EEOC's recordkeeping requirements say employers must keep all personnel or employment records for one year. If an employee is involuntarily terminated, their personnel records must be kept for one year from the date of termination. Federal law also prohibits discrimination in pay, promotion and other terms and conditions of employment, so the same criteria should apply to everyone in a role.
What to add:
- The same criteria and weights for everyone in the same role
- A filing rule: keep signed forms for at least one year, longer if your state or policy says so
- The employee comments box, so their side is on the record
⚑ Practical note: State laws can add their own rules on employee access to personnel files. Check your state before setting a retention period.
Evaluation Form for Employees in the Philippines
In the Philippines, the probation review carries the most weight. Get it wrong, and the decision may not stand.
Under Article 296 of the Labor Code, probationary employment can't exceed six months from the date the employee started working, unless an apprenticeship agreement sets a longer period. A probationary employee can be ended for just cause or for failing to meet reasonable standards made known at the time of engagement. An employee allowed to work after probation is considered regular.
Government agencies follow the Civil Service Commission's Strategic Performance Management System. Its IPCR rating scale runs from Outstanding (4.500 to 5.000) through Very Satisfactory, Satisfactory and Unsatisfactory down to Poor (below 1.500).
What to add:
- The date the criteria were given to the employee, ideally on day one
- The probation end date: six months from the start date
- A final probation review before that date, with the outcome recorded
⚑ Practical note: The Enerpize template suits private employers. Government offices should use the CSC-approved IPCR form for their agency.
Evaluation Form for Employees in India
India's rules changed recently. If your review process predates November 2025, check it again.
The Ministry of Labour and Employment brought the four Labour Codes into effect from 21 November 2025, replacing 29 older laws. The Code on Wages prohibits discrimination on the basis of gender in wages and recruitment for the same or similar work. Under the Industrial Relations Code, standing orders on conditions of service apply to industrial establishments with 300 or more workers.
What to add:
- The same criteria for the same or similar work, whatever the employee's gender
- A written link between the final band and any pay change
- Probation and confirmation terms from the appointment letter or standing orders
⚑ Practical note: Some Code provisions were notified in stages, and states issue their own rules. Confirm which rules apply in your state before relying on them.
Staff Evaluation Form for the United Kingdom
One date changes UK probation reviews: 1 January 2027.
Acas confirms that under the Employment Rights Act 2025, employees will be able to claim unfair dismissal after 6 months in a job, instead of 2 years, from 1 January 2027. Acas guidance on probation reviews describes them as formal checkpoints where managers should keep records. The ICO also confirms that employees can request a copy of their personal information, which can include notes about their performance.
What to add:
- Probation reviews before month six, each recorded on the form
- Comments written as if the employee will read them, because they can ask to
- The final probation outcome and its date
⚑ Practical note: A six-month probation period now ends right where unfair dismissal protection begins. Review well before the last week.
Who Can Use the Employee Evaluation Template?
Small Business Owners
Eight staff and no HR team. Fill in Settings once, rate everyone in an afternoon, and print eight one-page forms for the meetings.
HR Officers
Running the annual cycle across several managers? The Team Summary shows who's still Incomplete, and Calibration shows which evaluator needs a second look.
Supervisors of Shift Teams
Warehouse, security or delivery teams live by attendance. The Field & Warehouse profile weights Attendance & Punctuality at 25%, and the suggested rating comes straight from the numbers. In a retail business, the same applies to store staff on rotas.
Managers of New Hires
Set the review type to Probation (90-Day). The form won't show Ready until you record Confirm, Extend probation or Not confirmed.
Employees Preparing for Their Review
Fill in the self rating column first, with one example per category. You'll walk into the meeting with evidence instead of impressions.
Employee Evaluation Glossary
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Criterion | One thing being rated, such as "Arrives on time". The template has 18. |
| Anchor | A written description of what a rating looks like, so a 3 means the same thing for every manager. |
| Weighted score | The overall score after each category is weighted for the employee's role profile. |
| Band | The label for the score, from Unsatisfactory to Excellent. |
| Override | A change to the calculated band. The template requires a reason. |
| Self gap | The difference between the employee's rating and the manager's on one criterion. |
| Calibration | Comparing evaluators so one person's generous or harsh scoring doesn't decide outcomes. |
| Probation review | An evaluation at the end of a trial period that decides confirmation. |
Key Takeaways
- An employee evaluation form rates performance against set criteria, records evidence, sets goals and captures signatures.
- Rate 18 criteria on a 1 to 5 scale, and write what a 1 and a 5 look like for each one.
- Weight categories by role. In the sample, attendance is 25% for warehouse staff and 10% for office staff.
- Every 1, 2 or 5 needs evidence. Daniel's unexplained 5 is the one rating that blocks his review.
- Discuss self gaps first. Maria rated her punctuality 5; her manager gave 2 after 9 late arrivals.
- Compare evaluators before bands are final. Samuel's 4.33 average sits 0.51 above the company's 3.82.
- Only 14% of employees strongly agree their reviews inspire them to improve, according to Gallup.
- Keep records: one year under EEOC rules in the US, and UK unfair dismissal rights start at 6 months from 1 January 2027.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should be on an employee evaluation form?
Employee details, the review period, the criteria with a rating for each, comments with evidence, an overall rating, goals for the next period, employee comments and signatures from both sides. Our template adds self ratings, category weights by role and an attendance section with absence and lateness counts.
How do you fill out an employee performance evaluation form?
Gather evidence first: notes, results and attendance records. Rate each criterion from 1 to 5, add a fact behind any 1, 2 or 5, and compare with the employee's self rating. Then work out the overall rating, set goals with measures and dates, hold the meeting and sign.
What is the 5 point scale for employee evaluation?
A common 5 point scale runs 1 Unsatisfactory, 2 Needs Improvement, 3 Meets Expectations, 4 Exceeds Expectations and 5 Excellent. A 3 means fully meeting the standard for the role. Write down what each rating looks like, so every manager uses it the same way.
How do you write an evaluation for an employee?
Whether you use an evaluation form for employees or a blank page, lead with facts, not adjectives: "9 late arrivals against a limit of 5" rather than "often late". Cover strengths and gaps in each category, keep the language about the work, not the person, and finish with goals the employee can measure. Our Comment Bank gives starting points for ratings of 1, 3 and 5.
Does an employee have to agree with their evaluation to sign it?
No. On most evaluation forms, including ours, the signature confirms the employee received and discussed the evaluation, not that they agree with every rating. Give them a comments box to record any disagreement, and keep it with the signed form.
How often should employees be evaluated?
Most businesses run a formal evaluation once a year, often with a mid-year check-in, plus a review before probation ends. Regular informal feedback in between keeps the formal review free of surprises. The template's Review Type covers annual, mid-year, quarterly and probation reviews.
Who fills out an employee evaluation form?
The employee's direct manager completes the ratings and comments. The employee adds a self rating before the meeting and comments after it. In larger teams, HR reviews the results across managers, which is what our Calibration sheet is for.
Can I use an evaluation form for employees on probation?
Yes. Set the review type to Probation (90-Day), rate the same criteria and record the outcome: Confirm, Extend probation or Not confirmed. Check your local rules on probation length first, such as the six-month limit in the Philippines.
About the Author
Omar El Bahr is a Senior Digital Growth Specialist at Enerpize, where he leads SEO, content strategy, and organic growth across international markets. He is a Forbes Communications Council contributor and has written for Entrepreneur on business communication and digital strategy.
Disclaimer
This template and the information on this page are for general guidance only and are not legal or HR advice. Employment, probation and record rules differ by country and change over time, so confirm your position with a qualified adviser. This template is not a statutory form.
